Sunday, August 18, 2013

Broken Accusation: Internet Harrassment and Terrorism

The Accusation
A "smear campaign". This is Fu Ping's first response to the wide spread criticism on the factual accuracy of his memoir. In an interview with International Herald and Tribute in February, 2013, she told Didi Kirsten Tatlow that,
They smear my name, they try to get my daughter’s name on the Internet, they sent people to Shanghai to surround my family and to Nanjing to harass my neighbors.
A few weeks later, she raised the bar and claimed "this is Internet Terrorism."

The Debunking
None of the above accusations are true.

First of all, Fu Ping included her daughter's name in the "Acknowledgement" part of her book. It was also included in some of the earlier profiles on her success. For example, an article from her alma mater or an interview with WNYC.

The mystery of the Shanghai Villa where her family grew up has already been documented. Indeed, curious and diligent people have walked the streets in Shanghai tried to locate it but none have succeeded so far. It is therefore impossible to "surround" it.

Furthermore, members of Fu Ping's own family, including her mother, are all living abroad in USA. Her relatives in Shanghai have so far stayed outside of public controversy. Nobody has stepped up to validate her story. As a consequence, they are enjoying their privacy and could not have been "surrounded" by outsiders.

The only possibility is about her (former) neighbors in Nanjing. A couple of them did step up to provide information that refuted her story of her childhood. Unfortunately, most of these could not be substantiated either, for the lack of evidence and their choice of staying anonymous. However, there has been no complains about being harassed either.

3 comments:

  1. Ping Fu dedicated Bend, Not Break (her memoir) “to Xixi Edelsbrunner and Liyun Tang, my daughter and mother”

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ping Fu said that she wrote the memoir “in the voice of a mother talking to her daughter, not just any daughter, of course, but my own lovely daughter.”


    http://www.geomagic.com/en/community/pings-blog/advanced-remarks-of-ping-fu-at-the-2013-meeting-of-the-annual-am

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ping Fu has also said, this is a business memoir.... to her duaghter at the age of 18?

    ReplyDelete